When was 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ last sold?

The most recent recorded sale was in 2019 for $362,000.

What is the assessed value of 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ?

The total municipal assessment is $474,300 (land plus improvements).

What is 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ worth?

Our model estimates a market value of $568,178, derived from comparable recorded sales nearby.

How many units does 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ have?

Records show 1 dwelling unit at 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ.

What kind of property is 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ?

MOD-IV classifies it as Residential 1-4 unit (class 2). Year built: 1903.

parceldata.nj

Loading…

96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ — owner, sales, deeds · parceldata

96 Carey Ave

Butler Boro, NJ 07405·Morris County

1403·block 7·lot 24

$568,178estimated value

Last sale

$362,000

7/8/2019 · taxrecords_nj

3 other properties share this owner's mailing address.View portfolio →

Property

Type

Residential 1-4 unit

Tax class

Residential 1-4 unit

Year built

1903

Building size

2,190 sq ft

Lot size

0.22 ac

Land description

72X101

Building description

2S-F-O-1U

Dwelling / commercial units

1 dw / 0 comm

Tax & Assessment

Net assessed value

$474,300

Land value

$260,100

Improvement value

$214,200

Last year's tax

$10,652

Last MOD-IV sale

$362,000

MOD-IV deed date

6/28/2019

Owner mailing address

96 CAREY AVE
BUTLER, NJ 07405

Estimated market value

$568,178

range $501,140 – $674,605

moderate confidence

Assessment-implied: $545,172; Director's Ratio 0.8700 (2025)
Comp-implied: $575,211; 23 comparable sales

Estimated value, last 11 years

2016: $320,702 → 2026: $568,178

dots are actual sale prices for this property

Bordering

200-ft notice list →

13 Fairview Ave
Lot 1·$674,000
1 Van Buren St
Lot 1.07·$879,800
94 Carey Ave
Lot 23·$717,000
100 Carey Ave
Lot 25·$420,600

Block 7All of Block 7 →

Debug — raw data per source

Computed

{
  "isCondoMaster": false,
  "condoCluster": null,
  "siblingUnitCount": 0,
  "portfolioCount": 3,
  "portfolioKeys": {
    "fullKeys": [
      "96 CAREY AVE BUTLER NJ 07405"
    ],
    "zipKeys": [
      "96 CAREY AVE 07405"
    ]
  },
  "effective_unit_count": 1,
  "effective_unit_count_source": "MOD-IV"
}

MOD-IV

{
  "pams_pin": "1403_7_24",
  "county_code": "14",
  "district_code": "03",
  "block": "7",
  "lot": "24",
  "qualifier": "",
  "property_location": "96 CAREY AVE",
  "property_class": "2",
  "bldg_class": "17",
  "bldg_desc": "2S-F-O-1U",
  "land_desc": "72X101",
  "year_built": 1903,
  "living_sqft": 2190,
  "dwelling_units": 1,
  "comm_dwell": null,
  "land_value_cents": "26010000",
  "improvement_value_cents": "21420000",
  "net_value_cents": "47430000",
  "last_yr_tx_cents": "1065220",
  "deed_date": "2019-06-28",
  "deed_book": "23565",
  "deed_page": "1985",
  "sale_price_cents": "36200000",
  "sales_code": null,
  "owner_mailing_street": "96 CAREY AVE",
  "owner_mailing_city_state_zip": "BUTLER, NJ  07405",
  "mun_name": "BUTLER BORO",
  "calc_acre": "0.222000",
  "add_lots1": null,
  "add_lots2": null,
  "prop_use": null,
  "fac_name": null,
  "centroid_lon": -74.3328958004355,
  "centroid_lat": 40.99854891052341
}

SR1A

[
  {
    "id": "9f1b6b4f-e184-4032-899a-c782366fc2ca",
    "property_id": "7e681e3d-c93c-485b-b576-30df12d94daf",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "03",
    "block": "7",
    "lot": "24",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23565",
    "deed_page": "1985",
    "deed_date": "2019-06-28",
    "date_recorded": "2019-07-08",
    "sale_price_cents": "36200000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "taxrecords_nj"
  },
  {
    "id": "3bbacff3-2d6f-4638-9617-055d3a05d166",
    "property_id": null,
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "03",
    "block": "7",
    "lot": "24",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": null,
    "deed_page": null,
    "deed_date": "2019-06-28",
    "date_recorded": "2019-07-08",
    "sale_price_cents": "36200000",
    "sr1a_year": 2020,
    "source": "sr1a"
  },
  {
    "id": "bd81e05e-cc91-4ca6-b2eb-2905edebd02a",
    "property_id": "7e681e3d-c93c-485b-b576-30df12d94daf",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "03",
    "block": "7",
    "lot": "24",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23565",
    "deed_page": "1985",
    "deed_date": "2019-06-28",
    "date_recorded": "2019-06-28",
    "sale_price_cents": "36200000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  },
  {
    "id": "1b6e841f-2ae2-4e5d-bed8-f4559347477c",
    "property_id": "7e681e3d-c93c-485b-b576-30df12d94daf",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "03",
    "block": "7",
    "lot": "24",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "22614",
    "deed_page": "963",
    "deed_date": "2013-08-06",
    "date_recorded": "2014-10-31",
    "sale_price_cents": "27500000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "taxrecords_nj"
  },
  {
    "id": "00a161fb-2627-487e-9507-805aa906e3f5",
    "property_id": "7e681e3d-c93c-485b-b576-30df12d94daf",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "03",
    "block": "7",
    "lot": "24",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "22614",
    "deed_page": "963",
    "deed_date": "2013-08-06",
    "date_recorded": "2013-08-06",
    "sale_price_cents": "27500000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  },
  {
    "id": "2e651202-30e6-4d97-9828-53d51b70a377",
    "property_id": "7e681e3d-c93c-485b-b576-30df12d94daf",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "03",
    "block": "7",
    "lot": "24",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "4410",
    "deed_page": "33",
    "deed_date": "1996-06-25",
    "date_recorded": "1996-07-19",
    "sale_price_cents": "100",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "taxrecords_nj"
  },
  {
    "id": "f9fb89ee-aa86-4870-82b6-88ff6affbb3c",
    "property_id": "7e681e3d-c93c-485b-b576-30df12d94daf",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "03",
    "block": "7",
    "lot": "24",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "4410",
    "deed_page": "33",
    "deed_date": "1996-06-25",
    "date_recorded": "1996-06-25",
    "sale_price_cents": "100",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  }
]

API record·permalink

Frequently asked questions

When was 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ last sold?: The most recent recorded sale was in 2019 for $362,000.
What is the assessed value of 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ?: The total municipal assessment is $474,300 (land plus improvements).
What is 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ worth?: Our model estimates a market value of $568,178, derived from comparable recorded sales nearby.
How many units does 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ have?: Records show 1 dwelling unit at 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ.
What kind of property is 96 Carey Ave, Butler Boro, NJ?: MOD-IV classifies it as Residential 1-4 unit (class 2). Year built: 1903.

Address	Sold	Price
21 Spring St	12/29/2025	$850,000
46 Kiel Ave	12/1/2025	$560,000
24 Spring St	11/14/2025	$660,000
75 Roosevelt Ave	11/6/2025	$500,000
66 Gifford St	9/5/2025	$721,000
31-33 High St	9/3/2025	$685,000
74 Bartholdi Ave	8/26/2025	$571,000
42 Carey Ave	8/8/2025	$545,000
126 Kiel Ave	5/7/2025	$710,000
7 Scott St	5/5/2025	$460,000
81 Arch St	3/19/2025	$750,000
57 Carey Ave	12/27/2024	$570,000
28 High St	12/16/2024	$300,000
81 Arch St	12/9/2024	$865,000
15 Ward Ave	11/22/2024	$560,000
37 Central Ave	10/25/2024	$650,000
126 Kiel Ave	5/7/2024	$340,000
92 Boonton Ave	4/4/2024	$574,000
81 Arch St	12/19/2023	$185,000
17 Northwestern Ave	12/6/2023	$625,000
39 Bartholdi Ave	10/6/2023	$495,000
43 Boonton Ave	9/12/2023	$450,000
75 Roosevelt Ave	6/20/2023	$621,000

Sales history

7/8/2019$362,000
taxrecords_njBk 23565 / Pg 1985
7/8/2019$362,000
SR1A 2020
6/28/2019$362,000
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 23565 / Pg 1985
10/31/2014$275,000
taxrecords_njBk 22614 / Pg 963
8/6/2013$275,000
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 22614 / Pg 963
7/19/1996$1
taxrecords_njBk 4410 / Pg 33
6/25/1996$1
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 4410 / Pg 33

Date	Price	Book / Page	Source
7/8/2019	$362,000	23565 / 1985	taxrecords_nj
7/8/2019	$362,000	—	SR1A 2020
6/28/2019	$362,000	23565 / 1985	MOD-IV (Rutgers)
10/31/2014	$275,000	22614 / 963	taxrecords_nj
8/6/2013	$275,000	22614 / 963	MOD-IV (Rutgers)
7/19/1996	$1	4410 / 33	taxrecords_nj
6/25/1996	$1	4410 / 33	MOD-IV (Rutgers)